Table of contents for Short Rows & Sock Heels
OK, even I can admit that this short row heel obsession thing may be getting a bit out of hand.
But there’s another little gem of genius here worth sharing, in my efforts to eliminate the inelegant flap-and-gusset-style heel from the face of the earth.
I’ve seen where some people, especially men, prefer the fit of an F’n'G heel, because they find that a short-row heel doesn’t have enough room in it for them. So here’s an idea from a commercial sock that may be worth trying, if that’s the case for you –
This is one of those little "no-show" socks. The heel caught my eye one day, and after looking at it for a while, I realized what they did.
They started out by short-rowing "down", as we usually do for a standard SR heel.
However, they didn’t go as far "down" as is usual for a hand-knit sock: they did fewer short rows, so that something like half the heel sts are still live.
This will make for a wider, less pointy, and thus presumably roomier, heel.
But they didn’t stop there. Because if all you do is simply perform fewer short rows, it will also make for a much more shallow heel. That’s fine if you’re doing a toe, and you simply don’t want it to be quite so pointy — but not so fine if you’re after a bigger heel. Kind of cancels out the roominess factor. Uh-uh.
So what they did to give the heel adequate depth is this: they started short-rowing back "up", again just like we do — except about 1/3 of the way there, they turned around and started short-rowing BACK DOWN.
And then once again, they turned around and short-rowed all the way back up. Simple, no? Elegant, yes?
This should work with any short row method, but I’m jonesin’ to try it out with the double st short row heel (aka the yo-yo or jo-jo heel). I’v got a pair of two-at-a-time, toe-ups on one circ going, and with the amount of car time I’ve got this weekend, I may get a chance to play with this.
Happy holiday weekend, everyone! and Happy Knitting!
#1 by Sarah on May 12, 2009 - 8:57 AM
Quote
I have just started a sock heel that I wanted to make deeper after previous ones were too tight at the front of the foot between ankle and instep (round about where you start knitting around after completing the heel) and I am going to do it by taking a few stitches from the front half of the stitches on each side (working the shortrow heel on more than half of the total stitch count). I think that will make a deeper heel yeah? I will use your yoyo heel. Thanks for your analytical posts they must take a very long time to create but they’re extremely useful.
#2 by TessM on May 12, 2009 - 9:31 AM
Quote
Hi Sarah, I think you are on the right track — using more than half the sts will definitely make a bigger “pocket” overall. Not sure what the max would be, but also would depend on just how much more room you need/want. And if your problem is tightness at the front, then your suggestion sounds like it will fix the issue (as opposed to what this post shows).
From your email it looks like you are in New Zealand! You probably noticed we visited there last Xmas and had a GREAT time. Beautiful place!
(yes, some posts do take a lot of effort! but so good to know that people find them useful! thx!)